Analyzing and Argumentative Essay: Grades and Self-Esteem

Analyzing and Argumentative Essay: Grades and Self-Esteem

Length: 1092 words (3.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Analyzing an Argumentative Essay: “Grades and Self- Esteem”
What is self- esteem? Self- esteem is confidence in one’s own worth or abilities. In “Grades & Self- Esteem”, author Randy Moore (2007) stated that the level of performance of the students decreased while schools are building the self- esteem in the students. Author Alfie Kohn (1994) stated in his article “The Truth about Self- Esteem” to contradict Moore’s opinion that academics and self- esteem are not related. Moore discussed some beneficial points which are useful for the students, but in some cases his argument was not giving better meaning. I agree from Moore’s article that the American students do not perform as well academically as students from other countries. I do not agree from Moore’s opinion that the emphasis on self- esteem is responsible for the poor performance. Where as the student’s level of self- esteem may not determine his or her future, good self- esteem can motivate the student to study hard and reach his or her academic potential.
Randy Moore (2007) stated that people are complaining that students are not good in academic performance: “Only 11% of eight- graders in California’s public schools can solve seventh – grade math problems” (p. 118). Kie Ho (2007) gave an example of complaints by the immigrant that German said on his son’s first day as a freshman, his school included multiplication and division on his mathematics test (p. 112). Moore (2007) stated that, due to too many mistakes by U. S workers, the tasks are moved to other countries. In my opinion, the reason for outsourcing the work is that in other countries the labor cost is cheaper compared to America and also America has good economy, so Moore‘s opinion was not acceptable.


... middle of paper ...

...nce. High self- esteem could lead to over- confidence which engage the students in doing wrong activities. Low self- esteem could lead to depressions, which allow the students to attempt suicide. Both high and low self- esteem causes the students in different ways.

Ho, K. (2007). We should cherish our children’s freedom to think. In R. Spack (Ed.), Guidelines: A cross-cultural reading/writing text (pp. 112-114). New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
Kohn, A. (1994). The truth about self- esteem Phi Delta Kappan, 76(4), 272-283.
Kohn, A. (2002). The dangerous myth of grade inflation The Chronical of Higher Education, 49(11), p. B7.
Moore, R. (2007). Grades and self-esteem. In R. Spack (Ed.), Guidelines: A cross-cultural reading/writing text (pp. 125-126). New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Self Defeating Humor And Self Esteem

- Self-Defeating Humor and Self-Esteem Self-concept is an individual’s compilation of feelings, self-perception, and an idea of the basis of human personality. Self-esteem, usually identified in a positive approach, is the concept of one’s confidence in abilities and self worth, and the idea of self-respect. Self-evaluative standards evidently have a vital role in shaping future emotions and subsequent behaviors (Kuiper & McHale, 2009; 143.4: 359-76). According to Abraham Maslow’s Theory of Self-Actualization, self-esteem, notably confidence in oneself, respect for and by others, is achieved after physiological needs, safety needs, and love and belonging needs....   [tags: Self-esteem, Psychology, Mental health]

Better Essays
1326 words (3.8 pages)

Self-Esteem in Women Essay

- ‘’I’m too short’’. ‘’I’m too tall’’. ‘’I would be happier if I were skinnier, fatter, had bigger muscles, smaller ears, had straight hair, curly hair’’. Do any of these statements ring a bell. Are you used to demoralizing yourself. If so, you are not alone. As a teenager, our body changes dramatically, so does our physical image. These changes are hard to believe, seeing yourself transform into an adolescent. We sometimes have trouble adjusting to these changes, which can damage our confidence as well as affect our self esteem....   [tags: Self-Esteem]

Better Essays
1049 words (3 pages)

Personal Statement On Self Esteem Essay

- Self-esteem becomes the visualization of one’s value as a person. It develops over the sequence of a person 's life. Beliefs about self are based on the experiences throughout one’s life. These experiences have given messages about the type of person someone will become. A number of situations can negatively affect a person’s self-esteem. Negative experiences create negative beliefs. Visual, aural, or experienced events in one’s family, the wider community and school have influenced the views of a person....   [tags: Self-esteem, Childhood, Child, Female]

Better Essays
1085 words (3.1 pages)

Raised Strong On Self Esteem Essay

- Raised Strong Self-esteem is a personality trait that describes a person’s stable overall perception of personal value or self-worth. This is essential to human growth as it affects relationships, a person’s ability to work, and nearly all parts of life. Children’s development of positive self-esteem is extremely important as it allows for character building such as giving the child the chance to improve on mistakes without fearing rejection from peers. Parents have an extensive role in developing children’s self-esteem due to the limited number of outside factors that could affect a child’s opinions and self-evaluation....   [tags: Self-esteem, Psychology, Childhood, Emotion]

Better Essays
1062 words (3 pages)

Self Esteem And Young Children Essay

- ... During those years, I was not motivated because I was so shy. My life began to change when I moved away from home and rented my first home. I was on my own, working and life was good. As the years passed, I began to enjoy my independence. It was about that time that I was gaining confidence and began to emerge from my shell. I had more friends, and went out socially more often. I began taking classes at the community college and received good grades. During this time, I was cleaning houses. I cleaned houses for eight years and then decided that I could not perform that job my entire life....   [tags: Self-esteem, Motivation, Great Depression]

Better Essays
1227 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on Self-esteem and Academic Achievement

- The purpose of this present study was to examine several empirical studies in the relation to a set of self-esteem variables (ethnic identity, acculturation, and language) and academic achievement of adolescents and emerging adulthood from mainstream United States and three diverse ethnic groups (South Koreans, African Americans and Latinos). The findings and implications of the study including recommendations for future research in this area are discussed. Self-Esteem and Academic Achievement Research shows that academic performance influences a person's self-esteem, but it is still debatable whether self-esteem along with ethnic identity, acculturation and language influence academic achi...   [tags: empirical studies, self esteem variabilities]

Better Essays
1684 words (4.8 pages)

Essay on Self Esteem Of Adolescent Foster

- Self-Esteem of Adolescent Foster Youth in the United States The foster care system exists to provide a safe, temporary living arrangement to children who are experiencing abuse, neglect, or whose parents are not able to provide them with adequate care. Currently 382,400 children are in the foster care system, of which approximately 95,000 are adolescent youth ages 11 to 15. With the increasing number of youth in the foster care system and lack of resources the hopes of youth and families being reunited or adopted is shattered (Casey Family Programs, 2014)....   [tags: Attachment theory, Foster care, Self-esteem]

Better Essays
1388 words (4 pages)

What I Never Self Esteem Essay

- ... It has been knew that 59% of are dissatisfied with their body shape or concerned on what other people think of them. Although I don’t know any famous people I I do have a best friend who suffers from low self of esteem. She doesn’t want me to say her name. I began to ask her why she has low self of esteem. She applied that as a child her mother never told her she was pretty or ever hugged or .never once said she loved her and that played a big issue in her life. I then went on to ask her can she remember a moment that she went thorough that showed her she had low self of –esteem....   [tags: Self-esteem, Conceptions of self, Outline of self]

Better Essays
1074 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on Slavery and Self-Esteem

- Self-esteem Self-esteem is a term used to describe self-evaluation. The term self-evaluation is used to express that self-esteem is a product of personal reflection. A person with a high self-esteem has positive self-regard while a person with low self-esteem has negative self-regard. Self-esteem can be impacted by several external factors and is most impacted in the childhood years. Individuals who feel respected in their childhood are more likely to develop high self-esteem. Signs of respect include being listened to and being given attention....   [tags: Self Esteem, Race, Self Evaluation]

Better Essays
1857 words (5.3 pages)

Self Esteem Among Persons With Disabilities Essay

- ... This internalization of problems can lead to lower self-esteem as an individual may feel helpless and confused about how to resolve their problems. Thus, individuals with disabilities often suffer from low self-esteem which may be the result of different societal influences. Brittain contends that “the combined assumption that the [disabled individual’s] problem lies within the individual and their impairment and that everyone, especially adults, should be able to look after themselves and their own needs can lead people with disabilities into the false belief that they are a burden upon society and they are to blame for their situation” (441)....   [tags: Self-esteem, Disability, Mental disorder]

Better Essays
1271 words (3.6 pages)