Library Selection Policy Essay

Library Selection Policy Essay

Length: 888 words (2.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In order for a school to have an effective Selection Policy, there must be basic components to it. This author will attempt to compare the Selection Policy from Canutillo ISD to the components presented by the American Library Association. The ALA article states “a good policy on the selection of instructional materials will be relevant to your particular system and include basic sections on objectives, responsibility, criteria, procedures for selection, reconsideration of materials, and policies on controversial materials.” (Workbook for Selection Policy Writing, Revised 1999)
The Selection Policy from Canutillo ISD contains an objectives component. It summarizes the District’s directives in allowing “District professional staff to select and acquire instructional resources.” (CISD Board Policy EFA, 2002) The objectives section includes the definition of “instructional resources”, which this author feels could use further explanation of what “supplemental materials, electronic resources, and any other materials” comprise. (CISD Board Policy EFA, 2002)
The primary statement of policy includes the following: “Although trained professional staff is afforded the freedom to select instructional resources for their use in accordance with this policy and the state mandated curriculum, the ultimate authority for determining and approving the curriculum and instructional program of the District lies with the Board.” (CISD Board Policy EFA, 2002) There is no clarification of whom the trained professional staff is. This statement would be more effective in the objectives component so that the public is aware of where the final selection decision resides.
The CISD Selection Policy does not contain a procedure for acquiring resour...

... middle of paper ... reasonably possible, the committee shall meet and determine whether the challenged material conforms to the principles of selections set out on this policy. (CISD Selection Policy EFA, 2002) There should be a defined time wherein the committee shall meet. The ALA recommends that this be within ten working days of the complaint. (Workbook for Selection Policy Writing, Revised 1999) “The decision made by the committee is binding to the individual school.” (Workbook for Selection Policy Writing, Revised 1999) This fact should be included in the component for future complainants’ information.

Works Cited

Workbook for Selection Policy Writingm 1999. Retrieved from
Canutillo ISD Board Policy Online, 2002. Retrieved from

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Censorship and Selection Essay

- Introduction Censorship is a dirty word to information professionals. Attempts by individuals or groups to restrict the public from reading, hearing or viewing certain materials due to their content, is enough to send librarian's and organizations such as the American Library Association, to the proverbial battle field. However, information professionals from all fields have to make choices about what to include and what not to include in their particular library's collection. How are these selections made....   [tags: self-censorship]

Better Essays
1604 words (4.6 pages)

Collection Development Policy Essay

- A library or information unit must have a dedicated plan on having an organized Collection Development Policy, represents the guideposts of all types of library institutions. Collection development is the process of planning, selecting, acquiring and evaluating the library collections’ convenience to print and electronic collection developments. Thus, it is essential to have a written collection development policy, a statement of general collection building principles with desalinating the purpose and content of a collection in terms of relevance and internal audiences (Clayton and Gorman 2007)....   [tags: Library Science, Policies]

Better Essays
2010 words (5.7 pages)

Quality Management in Academic Libraries Essay

- ... The customer in an academic library is the student and the teaching staff of the institution. The primary purpose of an academic library is to support the teaching, research and other extracurricular activities of the institution. An academic library is a service organization which delivers services personally to the customers. In a service organization like an academic library the customer satisfaction means fulfilling users' expectation. For that the librarian must find out the needs of the users and try to provide it....   [tags: satisfaction, selection, services]

Better Essays
1287 words (3.7 pages)

My First Selection For The Best United Nations Commision Board Essay

- Problems are starting to add up in the world, and the President is putting the duty in my hands to help fix them. My objective to save the day is simple: Put together the best United Nations Commision Board possible, containing famous leaders in history or of today, to stop the madness around the world. The future has brought upon several issues around the globe, including social, financial, and military problems. Therefore, the people I have chosen to sit upon my Commision Board and help save the world are as follows: Calvin Coolidge, Huey Long, Jimmy Carter, Herbert Hoover, Andrew Carnegie, Harry Hopkins, Rosa Parks, Amelia Earhart, Samuel Gompers, and Gen....   [tags: Franklin D. Roosevelt, Herbert Hoover]

Better Essays
1860 words (5.3 pages)

Analysis the admission policy of primary and secondary schools in the UK

- 1. Introduction The value and role of “knowledge” is different in every culture but good basic education is essential in every culture. Primary and secondary education in UK (up to 16) is compulsory for all children. However, there were a limited number of high quality schools and these are oversubscribed application. That created problem of “distributing” pupils between schools (Hurst and Sugden, 2011). So a practical and effective admission policy has great influence on the quality of basic education....   [tags: Education, Butler's 1944 Act]

Better Essays
2148 words (6.1 pages)

Library Collections and Development Essay

- RUSA’s (Reference and User Services Association, a division of ALA) Standards and Guidelines Committee revised the existing guidelines for Liaison work in 2009. The standards and guidelines help librarians identify users that can help in collection services and issues. They also identify objectives and continuing education opportunities for liaisons. (2010, p. 97) According to the committee, liaison work is the mean by which librarians involve their patrons in assessing the collection to determine how satisfied the patrons are with it....   [tags: Library Administration]

Better Essays
1862 words (5.3 pages)

Yale Library Website Evaluation Essay

- The Yale University library is made up of twenty different buildings on campus. These building are designated for specific schools and subjects. Such as the Cushing/Whitney medical library and the Lillian Goldman law library. Each school provides subject specific services to their students and differs from other libraries on campus in policy and layout. Despite the differences between libraries they all share the same library homepage. The Yale University Library site brings all the libraries and buildings together for the ease of the user....   [tags: Yale University Library, Campus]

Better Essays
1175 words (3.4 pages)

Library Essay

- Recently, school library journals have been fraught with tales of gloom and despair – the libraries are closing. But dig a little deeper, scratch more than the surface, and perhaps we will find that not all school libraries are closing. In fact, the trend suggests that only libraries that are not meeting the updated needs of their students find themselves on the chopping block. Why. The traditional services offered by the traditional school library can no longer be supported under the weight of enormous financial constraints....   [tags: Library Science]

Better Essays
1667 words (4.8 pages)

Essay about Library

- Libraries are an essential part of the community. However not all societies have libraries. Libraries require centralized populations, economic development and political stability for their survival. Libraries exist in places where peace exists. They cannot exist in places with full of conflicts. Libraries have different missions and serve different communities differently. People and organizations establish libraries with different missions. Historical overview shows that libraries have always had missions....   [tags: Library Science, Information, Archive]

Better Essays
1137 words (3.2 pages)

library Essay example

- Library Collections Reference Collection - The collection contains on-line and print materials on all subjects, but focuses on those subjects that support the research needs of our students and faculty. Some of these sources are encyclopedias, dictionaries, handbooks, glossaries, directories, and atlases. Public computer terminals are located on both the first and second floors. Reference Desk personnel will provide instruction on accessing these materials. Contact the 1st floor Reference Service Desk at Ext....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
738 words (2.1 pages)